You’ve been sitting with that decision for weeks now. Maybe months.
You’ve made lists. Analyzed the pros and cons. Asked everyone you trust what they think. Read articles. Checked your horoscope. Gone back to the drawing board seventeen times.
And yet. The answer still feels just out of reach.
Here’s what I know about you: You’re not indecisive. You’re not broken. You’re just caught in the space between what your head is telling you and what your body already knows.
Let’s talk about how to stop overthinking decisions and finally trust your intuition, without abandoning your beautiful, analytical mind in the process.
The Real Problem Isn’t That You Think Too Much
It’s that you’re trying to think your way to a feeling.
Overthinking happens when we expect our intellect to do a job it was never designed for. Your mind is brilliant at analyzing data, spotting patterns, weighing options. But it cannot feel the rightness of a choice. That’s your intuition’s job.
And here’s where it gets tricky: most of us were taught to trust our thoughts over our inner knowing. We learned that feelings are unreliable. That logic should always win. That if you can’t explain your decision rationally, it doesn’t count.
So when your intuition whispers this way, your intellect jumps in with a thousand reasons why that doesn’t make sense. And you freeze. You spiral. You start the analysis all over again, hoping that this time the answer will feel clear.
But clarity doesn’t come from more thinking. It comes from learning how to stop overthinking and listen deeper.
Intuition, Intellect, and Emotion: Learning to Tell Them Apart
Before you can trust your intuition, you need to know what it actually is, and what it isn’t.
Your intellect is the voice that analyzes, compares, and problem-solves. It sounds like: If I choose this, then X could happen. But if I choose that, what about Y? It lives in the future, always calculating risk.
Your emotions are reactions to your past and present. They’re shaped by old wounds, fears, and unhealed experiences. They sound like: I’m scared this will go wrong. I don’t want to disappoint anyone. What if I fail? Emotions are valid, but they’re not the same as intuition.
Your intuition is the quiet knowing beneath all the noise. It doesn’t justify itself. It doesn’t need evidence. It just knows. It sounds like: This feels right. Or: Not this. It’s calm. Steady. Unshakeable.
The problem? We’ve been taught to mistake emotion for intuition, and then dismiss both as “irrational.”
When you’re trying to make a big decision and anxiety floods your system, that’s not your intuition warning you. That’s an emotional reaction, likely rooted in an old story about safety or worthiness. Your intuition doesn’t shout or panic. It whispers. And it waits.
Why Overthinkers Struggle to Trust Their Intuition
If you’re someone who overthinks, it’s usually because somewhere along the way, you learned that your inner knowing wasn’t trustworthy.
Maybe you made a decision that didn’t go as planned, and someone told you that you “should have known better.” Maybe you were raised in an environment where your feelings were dismissed or minimized. Maybe you were taught that being “smart” meant never making mistakes, so you started second-guessing every choice before you even made it.
You became hypervigilant. Over-responsible. Always looking for the “right” answer outside yourself because trusting your own instincts felt too risky.
And now? Your intuition is still there, speaking softly beneath the noise. But your intellect has become the loudest voice in the room, drowning it out with analysis, doubt, and what-ifs.
Here’s the truth: how to stop overthinking decisions starts with giving your intuition permission to speak, and your intellect permission to rest.
How to Access Your Intuition (Without Abandoning Your Brain)
You don’t have to choose between your head and your heart. The goal isn’t intuition over intellect, it’s intuition with intellect. Both matter. Both have a role.
But if you want to stop the spiral and make decisions that feel aligned, you need to strengthen your relationship with your inner knowing. Here’s how:
1. Get Clear on Your Intention
Your intuition works best when it knows what you’re aiming for. Vague questions get vague answers.
Instead of asking, What should I do? try: What choice will bring me closer to the life I want to live? Or: What feels aligned with who I’m becoming?
Clarity of intention creates a pathway for your intuition to show up with clarity, too.
2. Separate Emotion from Intuition
This takes practice, but it’s everything.
Next time you’re stuck in analysis, pause. Close your eyes. Place one hand on your heart and one on your belly. Breathe slowly. Then ask yourself:
Is this fear talking, or knowing?
Fear will feel tight, urgent, and reactive. Intuition feels spacious, grounded, and certain, even if it doesn’t make logical sense yet.
3. Strengthen Your Intuitive Muscle
Like any skill, intuition gets sharper with use. Start small. Practice trusting your gut on low-stakes decisions.
Which route to take home. What to eat for lunch. Whether to say yes to that invitation.
Notice the whisper before your intellect kicks in. Follow it. See what happens. Over time, you’ll learn to recognize your intuition’s voice in bigger moments, too.
4. Let Your Intellect Support, Not Override
Once your intuition speaks, then bring in your intellect to figure out the “how.”
Your intuition says, This is the direction. Your intellect says, Okay, here’s how we make it happen. That’s the partnership. That’s where the magic lives.
You don’t need to know every detail before you take the first step. You just need to trust the pull, and let your brilliant mind figure out the logistics along the way.
A Gentle Practice: The Intuition Check-In
If you’re facing a decision right now and the overthinking has you spinning, try this:
Write down the decision you’re trying to make. Get specific.
Set a timer for 2 minutes. In that time, let your intellect do its thing. Write every pro, con, worry, and logical thought that comes up. Get it all out.
When the timer goes off, put the pen down. Close your eyes. Take three deep breaths. Then ask your body: What do I already know?
Notice what rises first. Not the thought. Not the fear. The knowing. It might be a word. A feeling. A sense of expansion or contraction in your chest.
Write that down. That’s your intuition speaking.
You don’t have to act on it immediately. But you’ve created space for it to be heard. And that’s the first step to learning how to trust your intuition again.
When Intellect and Intuition Align, Decisions Become Effortless
The most aligned decisions you’ve ever made? They probably didn’t feel like decisions at all.
They felt like coming home. Like recognition. Like your whole system saying yes before your mind could even catch up.
That’s what happens when your intellect and intuition work together. The analysis supports the knowing. The logic validates the pull. And suddenly, the path forward feels clear: not because you figured it out, but because you remembered it.
You don’t need more information. You need more trust.
You Already Know
I’ll say it again, because you need to hear it:
You already know.
Beneath the noise, the doubt, the second-guessing: your intuition has been whispering the answer all along. It’s been waiting patiently for you to stop overthinking long enough to listen.
And when you do? When you finally let your inner knowing lead and your intellect follow? That’s when the big moves stop feeling overwhelming and start feeling inevitable.
If you’re ready to deepen this work: to learn how to stop overthinking and start trusting the quiet certainty inside you: I’ve created something for you.
The Authentic Expression Starter Kit is a gentle collection of tools designed to help you reconnect with your intuition, release the need for external validation, and make decisions from your truest self.
It’s free. It’s yours. And it’s waiting whenever you’re ready to come home to your own knowing.
https://mariaduckhouse.com | Let’s connect on Instagram
Buy me a coffee
